Many brands are using ‘Dry Clean Only’ labels even for clothing made with durable fabrics like cotton. Is dry cleaning always necessary? I hand wash my wool, cashmere, and certain silks, but I also own a few really delicate pieces that are definitely dry clean only. But how safe and eco-friendly are the dry cleaners? Kasi from The PeahenÂ researches our dry cleaning options, and gives us tips for home care. â€” AZ
A few weeks back I took in my go-to Elizabeth Suzann silk dress into an EcoClean (an eco-friendly dry cleaner in Austin) and sauntered out $17.32 broker. Yes, you read that right. It cost me nearly twenty bucks to clean a single garment.
The price was a big fat reality check that sometimes my finances limit my ability to live green. Iâ€™m able to spend more on organic and local food, but eco dry cleaning, at least the EcoClean version, is way out of my income bracket. Itâ€™s hard for me to write this without feeling like a total hypocrite, but I know Iâ€™m not the only one who canâ€™t afford it!
In fact, Iâ€™m such an idealist when it comes to sustainability that it led me start researching dry cleaning intensively. What was I paying for exactly? Are the alternatives really sustainable? There must be cheaper ones out there!
Itâ€™s PERCâ€™s world, everyoneâ€™s just cleaning in it
First, I have to start with the prime offender of conventional dry cleaning and explain why itâ€™s bad. PERC is the chemical your dry cleaners have been using for years to give you stain-free garments. Itâ€™s also a toxin that puts your health and the environment at risk. PERC can be labeled under an array of names and acronyms you should become familiar with:
Science lingo: Perchloroethylene, Tetrachloroethylene, Tetrachloroethene
Street lingo: PERC, PCE, dry-cleaning solvent/fluid, Dow-per (Dow Chemical brand name)
Health threat:Â Even with short term exposure, PERC canÂ impactÂ the respiratory, kidney and neurological systems. This can show up inÂ immediate mood and behavior changes, even dizziness and unconsciousness. Â Just in case modern day life wasnâ€™t throwingÂ enough bodily stress your way!
Prolonged exposure puts yourÂ liver, immune, hematologic and reproductive systemsÂ at risk.Â Oh, and add cancer to that listâ€”so much so that the EPA identified PERC as a â€˜possible to probable human carcinogenâ€™Â and issued a set of stringent guidelines to help limit our cancer risk to â€˜1 in 100.â€™ And hereâ€™s where it gets real crazy: the EPA guidelines focus on regulating dry cleaning machines to help prevent PERC from leaking into the air and surrounding buildings [read:Â major proximity risk!]. If you think secondhand smoke is unfair then you should definitely have a bone to pick with your local cleaner.
Environmental threat:Â In general, PERC is more of a health threat than environmental risk, but Earthâ€™s cycle exacerbates the problem. Because weâ€™ve been using PERC, largely unregulated and in massive quantities since WWI, it has leached intoÂ the soil and groundwater. Most of the polluted areas are still being cleaned up and manyÂ have even been designated as Superfunds. But all this cleanup is done in vain asÂ we continue to use conventional dry cleaning and add new pollution the surmounting problem.
Remember thatÂ conceptÂ your financial advisor mentioned calledÂ â€˜compound interestâ€™? Well, it works great for retirement saving, not so much for the environment.Â Thatâ€™s thanks to a principle calledÂ bioaccumulationÂ that causesÂ toxins like PERC toÂ compound at an alarming rate in our water, soils and wildlife. Because of it, local and federal governments are strugglingÂ to address the pollution issue, while also trying toÂ manage how to regulate PERCÂ in the future.
Why is PERC still around?
- PERC cleans fussy fabrics with minimal shrinkage and less fading than many alternatives. This is particularly important for structured garments like suits and blazers that canâ€™t stand up to much water without losing their shape.
- PERC is cheaper, as most chemicals are in a post-WWII eraÂ (this is a complicated topic for another day).
- PERC isnâ€™t branded by its chemical name. This means many customers mayÂ be oblivious that a carcinogen is usedÂ in the process. That, or they have no sense of smell?
Bottom line: PERC-based cleaning is still incredibly pervasive. The EPA saysÂ approximately 28,000 U.S. companies listed as â€˜dry cleanersâ€™ use PERC, thatâ€™s roughly 80% of the existing 34,756 cleaners. And the outlook for change isnâ€™t encouraging. Right now, California is the only state to enactÂ legislation toÂ phase out PERC by 2023. Cali is as big and as green as they come, but one state canâ€™t do the work for a nation.
If youâ€™re into the nitty gritty, read more details from the EPAÂ here.
DRY CLEANING MISCONCEPTIONS
If the information about PERC wasnâ€™t offensive enough, hereâ€™s the real kickerâ€”your cleaner and the clothingÂ industry have been feeding you misinformation to keep you buyingÂ into the conventional system. Please allow me to debunk.
No specialty cleaning option, whether it usesÂ PERCÂ or an alternative, is actually dry.
You may think water canâ€™t come in contact with luxury fibers and, because of this, also believe that dry cleaners use a 100% water-free process. Wrong.Â Your laundromat uses water likeÂ California gardener coming off drought restrictions.Â If youâ€™ve steered clear of water-basedÂ cleaners in the past, Iâ€™ve opened up a world of options for you.
Your garments that say â€˜dry cleanâ€™ or â€˜dry clean onlyâ€™ are probably bullshitting you.
Itâ€™s unclear if brands use this label to add an allure of luxury to their garmentsÂ or to avoid the finger being pointed at them if their clothes get damaged during the cleaning process.
Just because a cleaner isnâ€™t usingÂ PERC, doesnâ€™t mean their alternative is better.
Neo-cleanersâ€”those on-the-come-up in a post-PERC eraâ€”arenâ€™t all innocent either. TheyÂ can be prime offenders of greenwashing because no regulations govern their marketing practices.
For instance, the USDA mandates that an â€˜organicâ€™ label on food label must mean itâ€™s â€˜95% free of synthetic additives like pesticides, chemical fertilizers, and dyes, and must not be processed using industrial solventsâ€™Â (USDA).Â But in the cleaning industry, â€˜organicâ€™ can mean anything made of a carbon chain.Â If thatâ€™s the case, PERC is technically organic.
To help you figure out what the realÂ sustainableÂ options are, I broke them down by environmental impact and cost. This way, you can choose one thatâ€™s best for your lifestyle and budget.
DRY CLEANING OPTIONS
This is the oldest of the so-called â€˜green optionsâ€™ in which hydrocarbon, a petroleum derivative that comes from crude oil, replaces the PERC solvent in traditional dry cleaning systems. Although itâ€™s not quite as offensive as gasoline, hydrocarbon releases VOCs (volatile organic compounds) into the air that contribute to pollution. This obviously isnâ€™t an ideal alternative if we want to reduce our reliance on petroleum (the political and environmental reasons abound). Health-wise, hydrocarbon isnâ€™t technically harmful. That is, unless you consider preserving our longevity on Earth a health threatâ€”hey, like me.
This is also the option where youâ€™ll see the most marketing lingo like â€˜greenâ€™ or â€˜earth-friendly cleaningâ€™ without any information about the process.
Cost:Â Moderately more expensive than conventional PERC due to cost of solvent. Can be cheaper at times, especially in progressive areas where PERC is being phased out (Canada, California) and suppliers are choosingÂ hydrocarbon. This decision causes the market to swing and drives up cost of PERC.
2. LIQUID SILICONE
Better known by its patented name,Â GreenEarth,Â this is aÂ newer-gen PERC solvent replacement. In this method a Siloxane D5 (decamthylcyclopentasiloxane) solution (think of it as liquefied sand) removes odors and stains. ItÂ gets decent reviews as being one of the most effective alternatives for performance, but Iâ€™ve read mixed studies about the health and environmentalÂ impacts. Some argue that because D5 is â€˜naturalâ€™ and chemically inert it creates no water or air pollution. Other studies (readWSJ)Â speculate that D5, at high concentrations, can be toxic (based on lab tests).
Because it requires chlorine, the production of D5 alsoÂ releases carcinogenic dioxin into the air, raising an additional red flag. GreenEarth claims that it uses a closed loop process, but Iâ€™m honestly not sure if this is true. I couldnâ€™t find other sources outside of their website. Their whole marketing spiel is that D5 is a better alternative to bothÂ PERCÂ and water (should it become scarce). Right now, GreenEarthâ€™sÂ system is licensed in about 1,300 cleaners. Read theirÂ manifesto-ishÂ blog postÂ if youâ€™re curious for more info.
IMHO, the threats are nominal compared toÂ PERC. So, innocent until proven more guilty? Keep a close eye on this method in the news.
Cost:Â More expensive than conventionalÂ PERCÂ and hydrocarbon because the cleaner has to pay a yearly license to use the GreenEarth system, a cost they turn over to you. Â This is, unfortunately, what happens to innovationÂ whenÂ marketing and proprietary technology run the show.
3. CARBON DIOXIDE (C02)
This method doesnâ€™t replaceÂ PERCÂ with a differentÂ solvent. Instead,Â it creates a whole new cleaning system. Hereâ€™sÂ how the general process works: a compression machine converts CO2 gas into a liquid state, then it works with regular detergent to lift dirts, oils and stains. After, the liquid CO2 is converted back into gas and is compressed into a tank to be reused. During this process some CO2 inevitably escapes into the air, but because itâ€™s not a petrochemical, it doesnâ€™t contribute to global warming.Â TheÂ EPAÂ is on board.
A fair warning: I have read that customers have been disappointed if they go in expecting the same results as conventional dry cleaning. CO2 may not be as effective with tough stains or oils. If you find a credible cleaner, they should offer to redo your garment for free if you arenâ€™tÂ happy with the initial results. SoÂ buildÂ those human relationships!
Cost:Â Probably the most expensive option, depending how established your cleaner is. Thatâ€™s because a business owner has to make a significant investment in the technology required for CO2. This costs roughly $150K andÂ can be a heavyÂ financial burden for a small business to shoulder in the absence of government incentives. So again, theyâ€™re forced to pass this cost onto their customer, especially in the early stages.
4. WET CLEANING
Also known as â€˜SMART Wetâ€™ or â€˜PWCâ€™ for â€˜Professional Wet Cleaning,â€™ this is the same process you use atÂ home with fancier machines and better detergent. Whatâ€™s the value add then? PWC cleanersÂ put your clothes on special machines that reshape them after washing so you donâ€™t get rumples or creases from your drying rack.
BecauseÂ the jury isnâ€™t out on the other chemical alternatives, wet cleaning is your best option if you want to err on the side of caution.Â It also has anÂ EPA stamp of approval.
Rank:Â Best (if you value care over cost).
Cost:Â Everywhere I read while researching this post said wet cleaning isÂ comparably priced to PERC dry cleaning. Naturally, this makes sense because the machines and solvent are the cheapest to run and maintain. But that clearly wasnâ€™t my experience.
I canâ€™t get to the root of why EcoClean was so expensive because I couldnâ€™t find other cleaners to compare them to.Â It seems Wet Cleaning isnâ€™t widespread in theÂ US yet [the only other I found wasÂ Greener CleanerÂ in Chicago]. So help me figure this out, is there one in your city? What are the prices?
All I have to go on is the result of my dress, which turned out really beautiful. For me, the cost is prohibitive, but if Wet Cleaning is in your city and you can afford it, itâ€™s your best option. You can avoid the mistake I made byÂ asking about pricing and services upfront. For example, EcoClean offersÂ â€˜cleaning and pressing of dry clean only garments,â€™ which is what I chose as an novice customer. In hindsight, Iâ€™m not sure how this is different fromÂ standard Wet Cleaning or if my dress evenÂ needed it.
The cost should also includeÂ perks like free delivery and reusable garment bags.
Note: Donâ€™t confuse Wet Cleaning with sending away your laundry to a standard bulk cleaner. This is a goodÂ time saver, but itâ€™s exactly the same thing as washing at home in your own machine.Â Â It will run you around $1.65-$1.85/lb.
This goes without saying, but your cheapest and safest option is cleaning at home by hand and cutting out the service all together. If this isnâ€™t feasible in the case of specialty garments, or maybe your sink is sacred, I totally get it. Another trickÂ is to wash at home and then take your clothesÂ to a specialtyÂ cleaner just for pressing (no chemicals required).
Better cleaning starts with better shopping
The best advice I can give you is to start at the source: your clothing labels. Before you buy take note when clothes say they areÂ â€˜dry clean onlyâ€™ and opt for alternatives whenÂ available. If your label says simply, â€˜dry cleanâ€™ you can also consider homeÂ cleaning depending on the material.
Before you buy you can ask yourself questions like:
- Can I commit to the cost required for regular eco-conscious specialty cleaning?
- Is an eco-consciousÂ cleaner accessible to meÂ (find one)?
- Do IÂ have an alternative way to clean this garment cheaper at home?
- And, if so,Â will Â I realistically dedicateÂ the time and effort required?
Home Care Tips
If you think your â€˜dry cleanâ€™ garment will hold up to home care, here are some tips you can use before you try water submersion. Donâ€™t try these on hides of any kind!
If sun is an option, sometimes it soaks up the stink. Try this first. But please, read on if the stink persists, Iâ€™m not advocating that you become a social outcast here.
Save your liver the trouble and spray that stink with vodka! Alcohol kills bacteria the same way it kills your next day plans. Warning, give you garment a day in the fresh air before wearing or someone might mistake your newfound vodkaÂ TeetotalismÂ with a terrible vice upon first whiff.
Iâ€™ve addedÂ white vinegarÂ or baking soda to my steamer before and sometimes that helps.
I recommend the brushes for salon use to lift the pesky oils away. You can spray a little water or baking soda mixture as you go.
Okay, if itâ€™sÂ for reals dirty,Â none of the above options will really work. Donâ€™t be shy of water. It probably wonâ€™t ruin your dry clean only clothes (like I mention above). If itâ€™s silk, wool or cotton, itâ€™s fair game for submersion. Just make sure it doesnâ€™t have fancy beading or detailing. Youâ€™ll need a sink, biodegradable detergent (I likeÂ biokleen), cold water and a large towel for drying (NEVERÂ wring out nice garments.) Follow the stepsÂ here. If you’re sure whether you should hand wash your silk, see this how-to.
While researching this piece I came across a German system that uses a biodegradable solvent calledÂ K4Â thatÂ might hit the states. My fingers are crossed. Also, pay attention to the conversation happening around how your synthetic garments break down during the wash cycle and pollute the ocean (The Guardian). You can keep this in mind and opt for natural fibersÂ (no nylons, polys, rayons, spandex) that wonâ€™t break down in micro particles.
Read more from Kasi Martin on The Peahen.Â
iHow do you clean your ‘dry clean only’ clothes? Let us know in the comments below!